Centre for Competition Policy
High quality independent research into competition policy and regulation
Working Paper 14-8
Leniency Theory and Complex Realities
AUTHORS: Andreas Stephan & Ali Nikpay
ABSTRACT: This paper seeks to assess the robustness of the assumptions made by much of the theoretical literature on leniency programs, giving a glimpse of the uncertainties and complexities that apply in practice. First, sanctions are hard to estimate and the decision to form a cartel is not generally made by the firm as a rational monolith. Second, empirical evidence from the EU suggests an over-reliance on leniency, with only a weak threat of detection through investigations alone. Most leniency reporting may be occurring where a cartel has already ceased to operate or is very likely to be caught. Finally, the decision to come forward is not one that is taken lightly by the firm; it is fraught with uncertainties and dangers, including the challenges of ensuring cooperation from employees. The paper concludes with three recommendations for the strengthening of leniency policies.
KEYWORDS: Leniency; Cartels; Deterrence; Competition Law; Compliance; Corporate Governance.
CITATION: Stephan, A. & Nikpay, A. (2014), "Leniency Theory and Complex Realities", CCP Working Paper 14-8.
Publication Links
New Publications
CCP Book
Behavioural Economics in Competition and Consumer Policy
Subscription Members
The following organisations are subscribed to the CCP Membership Scheme and their support is gratefully acknowledged
[Membership of this scheme or use of members’ logos does not imply agreement by those organisations with any of the views or ideas published by CCP or any of its staff and students]
